Playing The Light In The Piazza – Guitar
Music/Lyrics: Adam Guettel
Book: Craig Lucas
Year: 2003 (original production, Seattle), 2005 (Broadway)
It is a rare treat for any guitarist to play The Light In The Piazza. Adam Guettel’s beautiful, complex neo-classical score is hardly typical Broadway fare, and the show is technically demanding for cast and musicians alike. 5- and 11-piece versions of the orchestration are available. The 11-piece version doubles its three violin parts, giving a total of 14 musicians required for a full production. This combination of unusual style, complexity and large production requirements means that the show is not frequently performed, and since only the 11-piece orchestration includes guitar, opportunities to play the guitar book are even less frequent.
I was lucky enough to play a concert staging of the show for Showtunes Theatre in Seattle, in September 2019. The well-received production featured a stunningly good cast and the full 14-strong orchestra. It was performed on the same stage where Piazza’s world premiere production took place in 2003, giving the event a special sense of homecoming. A brief YouTube video clip of the original 2003 production shows that the orchestrations had grown considerably on the way to Broadway. A fully-staged 2019 revival in London went even further, using a 40-piece orchestra.
In this article I examine the role of the guitar in the show, and describe my experience playing it. I provide tips for preparing to perform the score, and a detailed description of the equipment I used. I also provide an overview of the guitar book. A separate article (The Light In The Piazza – Detailed Notes On The Guitar Book) includes an in-depth commentary on the book and how I approached playing each number.
THE GUITAR’S ROLE IN THE SHOW
When preparing to play a show I like to consider the guitar’s significance in the ensemble by mentally removing instruments one by one from the orchestration. The idea is to assess how much each instrument would be missed, so I start by removing the least important, and usually end up with just the piano. In this case, I concluded that the guitar was probably the first instrument I would remove if I had to cut instruments because:
- The guitar has only a few exposed or solo moments, and most of these could be covered by other instruments if the guitar was removed (I address these in more detail below, and in my companion article, The Light In The Piazza – Detailed Notes On The Guitar Book.
- The guitar spends most of the show doubling other instruments, usually the strings or the harp, but occasionally the reeds. It certainly adds a particular texture to the ensemble, but this makes it far from indispensable.
A very notable exception to my assessment is #5: “American Dancing”, where the guitar part features very strongly, and would not sound the same played on any other instrument. Music Director Peter Hilliard, in his excellent, extensive blog post on Music Directing The Light In The Piazza, concludes (partly for this reason) that “the most important players are the piano, the harp, the bass, and the guitar…[t]hen the strings and then the reeds. But the orchestration is so good, it’s a shame to lose players”. The importance of the guitar, then, is debatable.
GENERAL NOTES ON THE GUITAR BOOK
The Light In The Piazza’s guitar book calls for nylon-string guitar, steel-string acoustic guitar, mandolin and (unusually) suspended cymbal. The nylon-string is the “main” instrument, followed (in decreasing order of importance) by acoustic guitar, suspended cymbal, then mandolin. Even though the acoustic guitar features in only two numbers, one of these is the most important moment for the guitar in the show: #5: “American Dancing”.
For the guitar, this is a relatively short, but challenging book. A few numbers by way of illustration:
- In terms of page count:
- The book has 69 pages, but 11 pages are either blank or numbers where guitar is Tacet, giving a total of 58 pages of played music.
- Of the 58 pages of played music, a further 9 pages have only suspended cymbal rolls, leaving only 49 pages of guitar and mandolin music.
- In terms of instrumentation, the picture is similar:
- Numbers in the show: 46 (including tags and transitions).
- Number where guitar is tacet or plays only suspended cymbal: 18
- Numbers featuring nylon-string guitar: 22
- Numbers featuring acoustic guitar: 2.
- Numbers featuring mandolin: 6
Additionally, there are long passages of rest in several numbers, so this is not a busy book for the guitar.
The book is detailed and accurate; I was not able to identify any errors, although I suspect there might be a few in #5: “American Dancing”. All page turns are good.
PREPARING TO PLAY THE SHOW
Playing guitar for Piazza is a very different experience from being in most musical theatre ensembles. You are part of a medium-sized orchestra rather than a pit band, and there is a quite different precision and discipline involved. There is almost no scope for ad-libbing or comping; you have to “play the ink”, which means you have to learn the ink. Even though the book is short, the music is difficult to learn and play, for several reasons:
- The material is sophisticated and challenging technically, in and of itself, involving unusual rhythms, additive meters, and frequent changes of time and feel.
- Many of the nylon string and mandolin parts are somewhat atonal, and make little sense outside the context of the full orchestra, so it’s hard to tell if you’re playing them properly as you practice alone; sometimes you feel as if you’re just playing random notes!
- To makes things even more abstract, the guitar has frequent, long rest passages, so when you practice, it often feels like you’re just playing fragments of songs and it’s hard to grasp the feel of a piece.
- Both acoustic guitar numbers are in an unusual D-A-D-F-B-D tuning, and are technically challenging for different reasons. They cannot be sight-read and have to be learned almost by heart.
To properly learn and understand the material, I recommend allowing plenty of preparation and practice time, to get the material “in your fingers”. Listen to and play along with the excellent Original Broadway Cast Recording, which includes all of the important numbers, with arrangements mostly identical to those in the book.
I also recommend adding plenty of vocal cues into the book, especially over the longer rest passages, to avoid getting lost in the maze of changing time signatures if your attention wanders for even a few seconds.
PLAYING THE SHOW
I cover this subject in detail in my companion article, The Light In The Piazza – Detailed Notes On The Guitar Book but a few points are worth highlighting in this more general article.
Once you get into rehearsals with the full orchestra and cast, the structure of the songs becomes more apparent. Even so, with the long passages of rest and the extensive use of unusual, alternating and additive time signatures, and frequent changes in tempo, it is easy to get lost. Maintaining attention to the book at all times and counting the rest passages is important.
There are a few quick changes between nylon-string and mandolin (particularly in #3” “The Beauty Is”), and to and from suspended cymbal and whichever stringed instrument you happen to be playing at the time. None of these changes is unmanageable. There are a handful of quick page turns, but again nothing impossible.
While I enjoyed playing the show very much and appreciated having the opportunity to do so, I wasn’t entirely happy with my work on this production. My preparation time was squeezed by work on other productions, and I think I underestimated just how complex the music is. The short rehearsal time and limited run meant that I never got to the point of feeling completely comfortable with the material. Having now learned it, and done some further study for this article, I would love another chance to play The Light In The Piazza, but as I have already pointed out, such opportunities are rare…
Finally, a particular pleasure of performing the show for me was being seated next to the harpist. The harp has some of the richest, loveliest moments in the score and our harpist, the wonderful Catherine Case, was a joy to listen to.
The score calls for four instruments:
- Nylon-string guitar: this is the main instrument for the Guitar book. I used a Takamine P3FCN, which has built-in a pickup and preamplifier. Takamine Pro Series guitars have a modular preamp system, and I have replaced the stock CT4B II 9V preamp with the 18V Takamine CT4-DX, which has a 5-band graphic EQ, 2 notch filters and a built-in tuner. It provides improved clarity of tone over the stock model. I ran the guitar output through a Radial PZ-Pre preamplifier, for further tone shaping and level control. I adjusted the EQ to provide a clear, warm classical guitar sound, with a hint of modern brightness (boosted upper-midrange).
- Steel-string acoustic guitar, tuned D-A-D-F-B-D: the steel-string acoustic is used for only two numbers in the show, but is tuned to something like a Dm6 tuning for both. I used my 2004 Atkin Small Jumbo, which has a built-in Fishman pickup. I ran the guitar through a Fishman Aura Spectrum preamplifier for tone shaping and level control. I went for a fairly bright sound for this show, because it suited #5: “American Dancing”, and provided contrast to the harp sound in #19: “Love To Me”, where the guitar is doubling the harp.
- Mandolin: I used a Michael Kelly F-style mandolin, with a built-in Fishman System 1 pickup. I ran the mandolin through an MXR M-108 10-band graphic EQ for tone shaping and level control. I went for a sound slightly brighter than I would for shows where the mandolin is playing solo. For Piazza, the mandolin mostly doubles string parts, and the brighter tone provided some contrast with the warmth of the violins.
- Suspended cymbal: there is actually quite a lot of suspended cymbal in the book. The percussionist for the show (Paul Hansen) kindly provided a cymbal, stand and mallets for me to use. The entirety of the part is simple cymbal rolls, usually with a crescendo. It’s very straightforward, although I am grateful to Mr. Hansen for providing me with a few tips on technique during rehearsals!
I set all three stringed instruments on stands to my right, which is my preferred configuration for a pit setup. All cables were routed around the periphery to keep them out of the way. The suspended cymbal was to the left of the music stand, and was within easy reach, even when holding a guitar.
As usual, I used an AER Compact 60 Mk.3 acoustic instrument amplifier. The amplifier served as my personal monitor, and also has a balanced XLR output, which was used to feed my signal to the house sound board.
All three stringed instruments were routed through the pedalboard into the Channel 1 input. All tone controls were set flat and I didn’t use the onboard reverb, as I had a reverb on the pedalboard. I set the gain to as high a level as possible without causing any clipping, and adjusted the master volume to suit the level I needed for monitoring (master volume doesn’t affect the level going to the XLR output). All volume, tone adjustments and level-balancing for the three instruments were made on the pedalboard, as described below.
Signal Processing & Switching
Since all three stringed instruments had built-in pickups, I took the approach of routing all three through a small pedalboard. Each instrument had its own “tone-shaping”/level control unit, and the signals were routed through a switching device, a volume pedal, a reverb. The typical signal chain was as follows:
Instrument (x3) → tone shaping unit (x3) → switching unit à volume pedal → reverb → amplifier
For tone-shaping, I used a Radial PZ-Pre preamplifier for the nylon-string guitar, an MXR M-108 10-band graphic EQ for the mandolin, and a Fishman Aura Spectrum preamplifier for the steel-string acoustic.
Switching: I used a GigRig Quartermaster QMX-4 unit to switch between the three instruments. I am particularly fond of the optical footswitches in these GigRig units, which in combination with the high quality circuitry produces absolutely noiseless switching (without even any clicks as you press the footswitches).
Volume pedal: I used an Ernie Ball VP Jr 25k (the version of the pedal for active signals). The “Jr” versions of their pedals are slightly smaller than the standard versions – always a consideration for small pedal boards.
Reverb: for this show I splashed out on a Strymon Blue Sky reverb pedal, the junior version of their fabulous, but very large Big Sky reverb. Strymon pedals have a reputation for being pricy, but excellent, and I can confirm that the Blue Sky is wonderful and was worth every cent (a quick shout out here to Seattle’s The Guitar Store, which stocks more pedals than any other guitar shop I’ve ever been to).
All of the equipment was mounted on a Pedaltrain JR pedalboard, with a Cioks DC10 power supply mounted beneath to power everything. The pedalboard also had a GigRig Cinco Cinco patch bay mounted beneath on the right side, through which all incoming and outgoing connections to the board were routed (this helped keep cabling neat). So, an example of the complete signal chain for one instrument (let’s use the nylon-string guitar) would be:
Nylon-string guitar → Cinco Cinco patch bay → Radial PZ-Pre → QMX-4 switcher → Ernie Ball volume pedal → Strymon Blue Sky reverb → Cinco Cinco patch bay → AER Compact 60 amplifier → house sound board.
This approach meant I could produce exactly the tone I wanted for each instrument, balance their relative levels, then feed a single signal from the pedal board to my amplifier and on to the house.
I used a Keyser Classical Guitar Capo for the nylon-string guitar, a Blue Chip CT55 pick for the mandolin, and my old favorite Big Dog Drum Stool. I prefer the drum stool because it gives you a bit more space around you than a chair, and this is often an important consideration in pit work. I used Sally Hansen Advanced Hard As Nails to keep my fingernails in shape while preparing for and playing the show.
The Light In The Piazza is wonderful score, which stands apart from most recent musical theatre repertoire in terms of its sophistication and style. Playing it is a rare and exciting opportunity for a guitarist (indeed, for any musician). Grab it if you get the chance, and prepare to be stretched; this is orchestral playing, not your typical pit ensemble gig. Allow plenty of time for preparation, and don’t underestimate the difficulty of the material, particularly the two numbers played on an unusually-tuned steel-string acoustic guitar.
LINKS – OTHER ARTICLES ON THIS SITE
The Light In The Piazza – Detailed Notes On The Guitar Book
LINKS – EXTERNAL
The Light In The Piazza Wikipedia Page
Licensing information (Rodgers & Hammerstein)
Original Broadway Cast recording CD and YouTube Playlist
Showtunes Theatre website and Facebook page
Broadway World review of Showtunes production
Video clip of original 2003 production at Intiman Theatre
The Light In The Piazza 2019 revival homepage
Peter Hilliard article on music directing the show
Catherine Case – harpist
Paul Hansen – percussionist